Accessories, Blog

The Best Dog Toys for Different Types of Chewers

Choosing the right toy for your dog is more important than it might seem. Toys are not just a means of entertainment for dogs; they serve crucial roles in your pet’s well-being, aiding in dental health, mental stimulation, and behavior training. 

The intensity and manner of your dog’s chewing behavior are pivotal in selecting a toy that is both enjoyable and safe for them. Different toys cater to different needs: while some are designed to be nibbled gently, others are built to withstand a barrage of teeth. Understanding the variety of available dog toys and their purposes can significantly enhance your dog’s quality of life by preventing boredom, decreasing stress, and avoiding damage to inappropriate items around the home.

Understanding Your Dog’s Chewing Style

Understanding your dog’s chewing style is crucial for selecting the right toys that satisfy their need to chew while ensuring their safety. This section will help you identify whether your dog is a gentle, moderate, or aggressive chewer, and guide you in choosing toys that best suit their behavior.

  • Gentle Chewers: Gentle chewers are dogs who nibble on toys softly, rarely causing any damage. These dogs often suck or lick their toys as well, showing no aggressive tearing or ripping behaviors. Gentle chewers typically do well with plush toys, stuffed animals, or squeaky toys that provide sensory interest without needing high durability. These toys offer comfort and gentle engagement but may not withstand harsher play.
  • Moderate Chewers: If your dog chews toys with some enthusiasm but doesn’t destroy them quickly, they likely fall into the moderate chewer category. These dogs need toys that can provide a bit more resistance and durability without being as indestructible as those meant for aggressive chewers. Rubber toys, thick ropes, and certain reinforced plush toys strike a good balance for these dogs, offering them a satisfactory chew experience without quick deterioration.
  • Aggressive Chewers: Aggressive chewers are dogs that exert significant force on their toys, often destroying them rapidly. These dogs require toys made from durable materials designed to stand up to intense chewing. The risks of choosing the wrong toys for these chewers include ingestion of broken parts, choking, or intestinal blockage. For aggressive chewers, it is crucial to select heavy-duty toys often labeled as “indestructible,” such as those made from hard rubber or tough nylon. These toys not only resist tearing but also help in managing the natural chewing instincts and strength of such dogs.

By understanding your dog and its chewing style, you can better cater to their playtime needs while ensuring their safety and the longevity of their toys.

Recommended Toys for Each Type of Chewer

Choosing the right toy for your dog’s specific chewing style can significantly enhance their playtime and well-being. This section provides tailored recommendations for gentle, moderate, and aggressive chewers, ensuring you find durable and enjoyable options that best match your dog’s needs and chewing habits.

Gentle Chewers

  • Soft Toys: Ideal for gentle chewers, soft toys include items like fleece tug toys and soft rubber structures that provide sensory pleasure without challenging their mild biting force. Benefits of these toys include their ability to entertain without risk of dental damage and their usefulness in interactive play, which can strengthen your bond with your pet.
  • Plush Toys: Plush toys are favorites among many dogs due to their soft, cuddly texture and often built-in squeakers. Best picks include machine-washable plush toys with double-stitched seams to ensure they hold up better under light chewing. Safety tips involve regular inspections for signs of wear and removing any toy that starts to tear, as loose stuffing and small parts can pose choking hazards.

Moderate Chewers

  • Rubber Toys: Durable rubber toys are excellent for moderate chewers, as they provide the necessary resistance to keep your dog entertained while being tough enough to prevent quick destruction. Durable options include toys made from natural heavy-duty rubber that can withstand more force than average toys. Brands like Kong and Nylabone offer various shapes and sizes that can also be stuffed with treats to increase interest.
  • Rope Toys: Rope toys are beneficial for moderate chewers because they can withstand considerable chewing and help clean teeth by acting as floss. Benefits include their durability and their ability to promote dental health. Safety tips for using rope toys include supervising your pet to ensure they do not unravel the toy and ingest the strings, and regularly checking the toy for excessive wear, replacing it when necessary.

Aggressive Chewers

  • Chew-Proof Toys: For the toughest of chewers, chew-proof toys made from materials like ultra-durable nylon or tough rubber are essential. Materials and brands that are well-regarded include the Kong Extreme line, Goughnuts chew toys, and West Paw’s Zogoflex toys. These toys are specifically designed to endure the jaws of aggressive chewers and often come with a replacement or money-back guarantee if they are destroyed.
  • Interactive Toys: Keeping aggressive chewers engaged is crucial for managing their chewing behavior. Toys that challenge their intelligence like treat-dispensing puzzles and interactive feeders can help redirect their chewing energy into positive play. These toys not only withstand rough play but also stimulate mental activity, which can tire them out just as effectively as physical exercise.

By carefully selecting toys that align with your dog’s chewing behavior, you can provide safer, more enjoyable playtime and a happier, healthier life for your furry friend.

Safety Tips for Chew Toys

Ensuring the safety of your dog’s toys is paramount to their health and happiness. This section outlines essential safety tips for choosing, inspecting, and maintaining chew toys. Learn how to select the right size and material, recognize signs of wear, and know when it’s time to replace a toy.

  • How to Choose the Right Size and Material: Selecting the appropriate size and material of a toy is crucial to ensure the safety of your dog. A toy should be large enough to prevent swallowing or choking but suitable for your dog to carry and chew comfortably. Materials should be non-toxic and appropriate for the type of chewer. For instance, soft rubbers or plush materials are ideal for gentle chewers, while durable rubber or nylon is better for aggressive chewers.
  • Signs of Wear and Tips for Regular Inspection: Regularly inspect your dog’s toys for any signs of wear such as deep teeth marks, tears, or missing pieces which could pose choking hazards. Check especially around any seams or areas where parts are joined together. Toys showing minor signs of wear should be monitored closely, and any toy that begins to break down should be removed from play.
  • When to Replace a Toy to Avoid Hazards: It’s important to replace a dog toy as soon as it shows signs of significant wear or damage. Pieces that become small enough to swallow or sharp edges that could cause injury should prompt immediate replacement. Additionally, toys that have been chewed into small pieces could cause internal blockages if swallowed, making frequent replacement and supervision necessary.

Interactive Play and Its Benefits

Interactive play is a dynamic way to engage your dog’s mind and body, promoting healthy chewing habits and strengthening your bond. This section explores the benefits of interactive play and offers practical examples of activities that can redirect excessive chewing while providing fun and stimulating challenges for your dog.

  • The Role of Interactive Play in Managing and Redirecting Chewing Behavior: Interactive play not only strengthens the bond between you and your dog but also provides significant mental stimulation and energy expenditure. For dogs with intense chewing habits, interactive play can help redirect their energy from destructive chewing to constructive engagement with toys that challenge their minds and bodies.

Examples of Interactive Play Sessions Using Different Toys

  • Tug-of-War: Using a durable rope toy, engage your dog in a tug-of-war that provides both physical and mental exercise. This game is particularly good for moderate to aggressive chewers, as it uses up a lot of energy and satisfies their need to pull and chew.
  • Fetch with Durable Balls: Throw a durable rubber ball or a disc for your dog to retrieve. This not only uses their energy but also practices their ability to obey and follow commands, which can distract from destructive chewing.
  • Puzzle Toys: Fill a puzzle toy with treats or kibble to stimulate your dog’s problem-solving skills. As they figure out how to retrieve the treats, they engage different parts of their brain, which can help alleviate boredom and prevent inappropriate chewing.
  • Hide and Seek with Toys: Hide your dog’s favorite toys around the house or yard for them to find. This game enhances their sniffing and foraging skills and adds variety to their playtime.

By integrating these safety tips and interactive play sessions into your routine, you can ensure your dog enjoys their toys in the safest and most beneficial ways possible.

Maintaining and Cleaning Dog Toys

Regular maintenance and proper cleaning of dog toys are essential for ensuring they remain safe and enjoyable for your pet. This section offers best practices for cleaning and disinfecting various types of dog toys, along with helpful tips on how to store them to prolong their life and maintain their quality.

Best Practices for Cleaning and Disinfecting Various Types of Dog Toys

  • Soft and Plush Toys: These can often be machine washed on a gentle cycle using a pet-safe detergent. For extra sanitation, you can also use a gentle disinfectant suitable for fabrics. Air drying or using a dryer on a low setting is recommended to avoid damaging the toy.
  • Rubber and Nylon Toys: Clean these with warm soapy water, scrubbing off any stubborn dirt or saliva build-up. You can also soak them in a mixture of water and vinegar for a few minutes to disinfect them further, then rinse thoroughly to remove any residual vinegar.
  • Rope Toys: Rope toys can be washed in a washing machine in a pillowcase to keep them from unraveling. Use a mild detergent and let them air dry completely to prevent mold growth.

Storage Tips to Keep Toys Safe and Durable

  • Keep toys in a dry, ventilated area to avoid the buildup of mildew or mold, especially important for plush and rope toys.
  • Use a dedicated toy box or bin to store your dog’s toys. This not only keeps them in one place but also teaches your dog where their toys are kept.
  • Rotate toys regularly to keep your dog interested and engaged, and to prevent excessive wear on any single toy.


Choosing the right toy for your dog based on their chewing style is more than just a matter of play; it’s an essential component of their overall health and happiness. Different toys cater to different chewing behaviors, from gentle nibbling to aggressive chewing, and finding the right fit can prevent both boredom and damage to inappropriate objects around the home.

We encourage you to closely observe your dog’s reaction to various toys. Notice which ones they return to and which ones are neglected or destroyed. Adjust your choices based on these observations to better meet their needs and extend the lifespan of their toys. By engaging with your dog in this way, you not only enhance their playtime but also strengthen the bond you share, ensuring countless hours of fun and healthy play.